Comments for This time it's for real: new Dune movie confirmed at http://sffmedia.com , comment 1 to 96 out of 20 comments http://sffmedia.com Sat, 07 Nov 2009 13:07:04 +0100 FeedCreator 1.7.3 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-830 I wonder if that was really the actor Steve Innes who posted back on July 2? There is nothing anywhere on who has been cast in this movie or if it's even going ahead? - Wendra The Bent Sat, 05 Sep 2009 10:43:24 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-829 Say what you will about Lynch's Dune, the casting will likely never be matched. Sting. Jurgen. Franchesca Annis. Kyle McLaughlan. PATRICK STEWART! Max Von Sydow! Linda Hunt (who had a nice string of roles around that time ... Shadout Mapes). Brad Dourif (the Baron's Mentat). I hated Lynch's version of the Dune story, but as a film in many way it stands on its own feet. Hopefully, the 3d times the charm. It's the story, stupied. - Driving a harvester Sat, 05 Sep 2009 10:05:14 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-817 I read Dune when I was in High School in the late 60's and became quite familiar with it. It is truly one of the best SF stories of all time. I have never been able to watch all of Lynch's Dune. I just don't like it. The SciFi miniseries (I am including Children of Dune) is the standard for following the book(s) and the feel of the book(s). A bigger budget could have improved the graphics for the SciFi version especially some of the desert scenes. I am looking forward to another try. - Terry Mon, 24 Aug 2009 23:15:10 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-813 + i bet (in these troubled times) hollywood studios won't be keen on promoting a very middle eastern inspired film, both in style and content - which is what the book is FULL of. Its what it needs too. I hope they can see passed prejudice, we've got a very unflattering view of American attitudes towards the middle east here. Prove us wrong pete x - jayoh Thu, 20 Aug 2009 23:57:21 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-812 Originally, Frank Herberts book of Dune was released in to stages: "Dune world" and "the prophet of Dune" - thats how they should make a a film of it (I'm very dubious about the directing experience and apparent attitude of Peter Berg, but willing to give him a chance at least. I liked the miniseries and the same people who produced that are billed to be producing this new one, so there's that at least.) One of the most dangerous hurdles for any hollywood production is CASTING. They should go for more unusual, lesser known actors that have bags of talent and less celebraty. The less americans in it the better :D NOT freaking robert pattison as muad'Dib though!! He'd suit feyd better x - jayoh Thu, 20 Aug 2009 23:42:31 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-736 I am SO happy to hear they are making another Dune....anything Dune is fine with me! I was reading the lists above, and decided to add my own two cents worth: Paul - the kid who played Superman on Smallville (TV series) Feyd Rautha= the kid who played Lex Luthor on the same Smallville series Duke Leto=Christian Bale Lady Jessica=Angelina Jolie Gaius Helen Moheim=Tilda Swinton Baron Harkonnen=James Gandolfini Gurney Halleck=Daniel Craig Stilgar=Hugh Jackman Chani=Allysa Milano Irulan=Nicole Kidman Emporer Shaddam V=Patrick Stewart Rabban=some mean big guy - Debra Mace Mon, 06 Jul 2009 07:23:30 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-733 Hi guys, Berg Fan is pretty much on the money for except one point: I didn't read for Leto, rather Duncan Idahao and Gurney, both characters being favourites of mine and more suited to me than probably any other. My agent called me to say that the role of Leto was probably suited better to someone in his 50's, so 'Im too young in any case. The roles of Duncan and Gurney however, are pretty much open to own nterpretation as far as age is concerned so we played it this way. No, my daughter is not being considered for the role of Alia. She is only 2 and Alia will be at least 4 in this story by the time she is relevant. To those who have reported I read for and/or got the role of Feyd Rautha: Wrong! I did no such thing. Indeed, I am not guaranteed anything at his stage. Like hundreds of others I was nominated by our agents, read for parts, done screentests and have attended call-backs, some more often than others. Like all the others I hope that success will eventually arrive but it is by no means a certain thing. S.I. Perth, Australia. - Steve Innes Thu, 02 Jul 2009 07:58:46 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-729 This is coming along quicker than expected as far as casting is concerned. Steve Innes, the Aussie actor (but British born, Jo!) looks set to take on the (much expanded) role of Gurney Halleck, though he read for Duke Leto initially. Steve (39) is also to be the next Mad Max when MMIV is filmed in Australia this year or next. A bit of trivia: Steve Innes is from Perth, same as Sam Worthington and the late, great Heath Ledger. - Berg Fan Fri, 26 Jun 2009 18:46:29 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-718 I think Berg will bring better character development to the movie. I liked the Lynch Dune but the characters and dialouge were rather stiff. - pmpbot2000 Sat, 20 Jun 2009 09:21:53 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-717 I say give Berg a chance. A lot of people are slagging Berg off even before he's had a shot. I am willing to let him have one: he says he is a big fan of Dune. OK so I dont agree with all his comments on Dune and I really didn't like Hancock but, the studios know with LoTR, HP and Trek that hardcore fans can be kept reasonably happy if the plot, atmosphere and philosophy of the original is preserved: Berg has said he is well aware of fan sensitivities and I have high hopes. - Rufus McDufus Sat, 20 Jun 2009 03:28:07 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-716 BRITISH actors please!!! - Jo Fri, 19 Jun 2009 15:11:24 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-681 Well said, Just a Lad. I saw the 1984 film before I read the books, and while I do wish the film had stuck more closely to the books, on its own it wasn't a bad film. The miniseries tried harder to stick to the books (Yay?). Shame it was awful. It LOOKED stupid and FELT wrong somehow. Doesn't help that I've ever liked that style of costume in any sci-fi or fantasy, let alone in a dark and gritty setting like Dune. The film had some amazing casting, even if it did go astray. And I agree, the internal monologs and such will be hard to do, they are a significant part of what make the books so damned good. That said, I will be going to see this new film when it comes out, and I hoop they do it justice whether it takes one film or three to do just the first book. I would rather see no film at all than another unsatisfactory effort. - Aryn Sun, 24 May 2009 19:06:17 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-673 I vote to open source the script. - Raleigh Fri, 22 May 2009 21:09:50 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-641 I'm over the moon that Peter Berg is doing a remake of Dune. I've always been a huge fan of Dune. I read most of the novels and I don't think there's any other sci-fi story that could equal the complexity and the genius of Frank Herbert's books. Star Wars is good but it is light-years away from the powerful vision of Frank Herbert's future Galactic Empire. Dune is the source of all great science fiction works. I believe the David Lynch 1984 version is absolutely amazing. I love that film and I wish I could kill the people who dare say it's crap. Maybe it is crap in America, but here in Europe it is considered a Cult Movie! Why? It is absolutely stunning! The special effects are not that good, but it is the scenario is unique. It is very onirical in its way and very prophetical. I love the 'atmosphere' of the film. I love dreams. That film was not meant to be adventurous or full of action-packed special effects in the first place. That was the big misunderstanding. The film is much deeper than that...I'm sorry you special effect lovers, but science fiction should not always be so damn clichè....David Lynch is a genius and his film adaptation of the novel is a master piece. Do you wanna know what's real crap? The 2000 mini-series is horrible!!!!!! it is an insult to Frank Herbert and it is simply ridicoulous! Children of Dune is a lot better, but still it is no match for the novels or the Lynch film. It looks like Star Trek!!! I'm longing to see the new version by Peter berg but i'm sure it won't beat the 1984 movie! I'm so happy that this film has more fans here in Europe that overseas. - LucaX Wed, 13 May 2009 14:37:49 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-582 Whoa... I was so excited about 3 months ago that I could scarcely contain myself. A new DUNE film!!!!!! But now I can't help thinking - in the current financial climate, does any Hollywood studio really have enough "spice" to bankroll a film like DUNE. After all, in order for any of us to like it (and not be as deeply critical and overly analytical as we obviously are) the film will need to redefine the term "epic" in every dimension of it's presentation. And epic costs money right? And David Lynch didn't have quite enough money, did he? ... And the Sci Fi Channel didn't have enough money either, did they? ... Much as it pains me to suggest this, I would rather wait until the time is right for this project to come to fruition. Maybe that's no time soon. - Warwick Sat, 04 Apr 2009 12:35:18 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-567 I believe in all fairness Lynch was forced to compromise due to the lack of financial support. This constraint alone made it damn near impossible for him to to do the Dune novel justice. I also remember thinking to myself ,before the original movie came out, that this story would never be fully understood by common folk who had not read the novel. I think I was correct. Perhaps this new film will have a better chance at the box office since more people who have read into the Dune universe. One can only pray this might be true. - Thunderstorm Witch Sat, 28 Mar 2009 06:54:03 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-558 Know your subject. Lynchs was not the first film/ The movie can be made. Shame on you who criticise lynch's film cut down from a ridiculous 5 hours to 2. For many of us, it made us look for the books. IS that not enough? Who knows that the original was going to be done by weirdo Chilean diredtor Jawdowsky and star Salvador Dali as Emporer and feature pink floyd as the soundtrack with sets desgined by Giger from Aliens fame. Think on that. It can only be done in parts, with each ending the audience wanting more (which is how Herbert describes his endings in an interview, he wants us to fill in/wish the rest of the hanging endings. He even admittted to the comment about Concubines spoken by Jessica "history will call us wives" being pure melodrama.) The second movie can destroy the messiah. Thats what the second and third book is all about. Aside from the ridiculous godly rain, Lynch never went beyond that point. He didnt misrepresent anything. yeah, weirding modules were silly. We can criticise afters its done, good luck. Drunkenly out. - Just a lad Sun, 15 Mar 2009 02:23:15 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-525 There is so much potential with the Dune universe, personally I think it's time to give Dune the credit it deserves and bring it to the forefront of the Sci Fi genre! The 1984 Dune David Lynch's version had the perfect atmosphere of mystic and wonder of the Arrakian desert and in addition the style uniqueness of the great houses and their allies! - Anunnaki Fri, 06 Mar 2009 21:47:52 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-522 I look forward to see all of the novels as movies - zuberee Thu, 26 Feb 2009 21:19:24 +0100 http://sffmedia.com/films/science-fiction-films/179-this-time-its-for-real-new-dune-movie-confirmed.html#comment-517 Heretics Of Dune will make the best movie, if they ever get that far. It is better than Children, and I don't see how God Emperor translates to film well because Leto's body would be too hard to make convincing, and most of the book is him talking -- a great read though. If done correctly there are two trilogies here with great characters and excellent story arcs: first the rise of Mua'dib through his death and then the ascendancy of his son, and second starting with Heretics, the destruction of Rakis, the defeat of the Honored Matres, escape on the no-ship, and culminating in the final battle with the machines. Though you would have to rewrite the ending because the current one sucks. Looking forward to steamy scene with Duncan and Murbella : ) - Rob Tue, 24 Feb 2009 11:25:43 +0100